//

Three Men by a Lake.

(Photo by Win McNamee / POOL / AFP via Getty Images)

The meeting was held at Kylin Villa, a lakeside resort outside Shenzhen.

Advertisement

It sounds like a place you’d go to get away from your troubles.

The three men who met there Thursday brought most of the world’s troubles with them.

President Trump, China’s Xi Jinping and Russia’s Vladimir Putin had never met as a threesome before. No American, Chinese, and Russian leaders ever had.

They met on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, and the subject Trump most wanted to raise has hung over all three countries longer than most of us have been alive. It was the bomb.

Advertisement

Trump said the three nations are “uniquely positioned” to talk about shrinking the world’s nuclear arsenals. That isn’t a boast. It’s arithmetic. Together, they hold the vast majority of the world’s warheads. If cuts are ever going to mean anything, these are the people who have to agree to them.

Then he said something presidents don’t usually say.

He admitted that giving up weapons is hard for any national leader.

It is hard. Nobody wants to be the one who goes first and finds himself exposed. Every leader in that room has generals, rivals and a domestic audience telling him not to blink. Saying so out loud isn’t weakness. It describes the problem honestly, and you can’t solve a problem you won’t describe.

It also matters that the conversation happened at all. The New START treaty, the last real limit on American and Russian arsenals, has lapsed, and the old arms-control framework is mostly gone. Beijing has refused for years to join three-way nuclear talks. Its argument is that its arsenal is too small to count.

On Thursday, Xi was in the room while the subject was on the table.

According to Chinese state media, Xi presided. He talked about peace among the great powers and called for nuclear weapons to be done away with entirely. That’s a fine thing to say, and it would land harder coming from a country that hasn’t spent recent years adding to its stockpile. Still, he said it, and it’s on the record.

On Ukraine, Trump said he and Putin had talked at length about ending the war. Putin said the three countries share an interest in settling regional conflicts, including Ukraine. Xi said nothing about Ukraine. In diplomacy, silence tells you something too.

Trump also raised two things Americans will recognize as their own business. One was keeping Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. The other was keeping energy moving through the Strait of Hormuz, the narrow waterway through which much of the world’s oil passes.

Before the three sat down, Trump met with the others individually and spoke warmly of both relationships. You can call that flattery. You can also call it how this kind of work gets done: through personal contact, repeated over years, until a meeting like this becomes possible.

Nobody expected a breakthrough, and none came. The White House called it an opening conversation, and it wasn’t clear whether there would be a joint statement.

Some will reach for Yalta. That’s a big comparison for a first meeting. Yalta is remembered for dividing up a world. This was about whether three wary powers could talk calmly about not ending one another.

Nothing was signed in Shenzhen, and maybe nothing will be for a long while. But the three of them sat down together, and the first thing on the table was the most dangerous thing any of them owns.

That’s a reasonable place to start.

Previous Story

The Embrace at Shenzhen.