//

Poll: It’s Not That They Left. They Just Didn’t Come.

(Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images)

The 2026 midterms are being told as a story of rejection. The new numbers say they were a story of absence.

Advertisement

Americans didn’t turn on the Republican Party this month so much as fail to turn up for it. That’s what a postmortem from pollster J.L. Partners found, as first reported by the New York Post. More than two-thirds of the Democratic wave came from Trump voters who stayed home, not from Trump voters who changed their minds.

The firm surveyed 1,000 registered voters on Election Day and checked the results against more than 30,000 interviews from the campaign. Thirty-five percent of the people who voted for Donald Trump in 2024 didn’t vote on Nov. 3. Only 8% crossed over to the Democrats.

Do the arithmetic and it gets clearer. Democrats gained 15 points on the 2024 result. Ten of those points came from Republicans who sat it out. Five came from Republicans who switched.

That isn’t a realignment. It’s a missed appointment.

Advertisement

“The GOP should not throw the MAGA baby out with the bathwater just yet,” said James Johnson, the firm’s founding director. “If Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again.”

Who Stayed Home

The empty chairs were at the center of the coalition. Among Trump’s 2024 voters, 46% of those without a college degree didn’t vote. Neither did 44% of those over 65 or 39% of rural voters.

These are the people who built the Trump movement: small-town voters, working people, older Americans who stood in line for him two years ago. This fall, a lot of them didn’t get in line at all.

“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House,” Johnson said. “That is how important turnout was at this election.”

Turnout alone would have done it.

The President’s Point

This is the case President Trump has made since the returns came in: Republicans lost because his name wasn’t on the ballot. He spent the campaign asking supporters to vote as if it were. Many didn’t. Midterms have always been hard on the party in the White House, and a name on a rally banner doesn’t pull people out like a name on the ballot does.

“If Trump was on the ballot, you would have expected a better result,” Johnson said.

Not everyone in the party agrees. The day after the election, Vice President JD Vance wrote on X that “the main problem is not turnout,” and blamed the Trump voters who crossed over. The J.L. Partners data points the other way.

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis gave his own explanation on Fox News: “a lot of our voters who stayed home, they stayed home because they were frustrated with the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate. That’s just a fact.” It’s a reminder that staying home sends a message too, and this one may have been meant for Congress.

The Ones Who Wandered

The defectors were fewer, and they were different. Eight percent of Trump’s 2024 voters backed a Democrat for the House. Among voters under 30 it was 16%. They skewed younger, male, nonwhite and urban, which makes them the same new voters Trump brought in two years ago.

They haven’t gone far. Half still view the Republican Party favorably, and 41% approve of the job the president is doing. They aren’t converts. They’re visitors.

The Other Side’s Problem

Democrats won the night, but the poll suggests they didn’t win much of an argument. Nearly half of Democratic voters, 48%, said their vote was against Trump, not for anything their party offered.

Registered voters were also asked whether the Democratic Party has a candidate ready to be president in 2028. Just 30% said yes. Even 29% of Democrats said no.

A party can ride a wave without knowing where it’s headed. It can’t do that for long.

For Republicans the lesson is plain, and it’s a hopeful one. The voters aren’t gone. They’re waiting for a reason to come back.

The poll’s margin of error is 3.4 percentage points overall and 10.5 points for the 87 defectors.

Previous Story

Bessent Moves to a Military Base. Trump Warns Iran.